I am a Pen name, but I'm also have a Master's of Accounting, CPA, CFE and CICA. 30 years ago, I did an extensive number of minister's tax returns. Nevertheless, I do agree with what you said. Make SURE the person is a CPA, not simply a tax preparer. That said, few CPA's do a significant number of minister returns and ministers are a truly unique animal. In my practice, I was successful in a tax audit to get a minister's tithe revamped as a business expense. This came from a ton of research and I was treading new ground. It was a unique ruling, but I actually wished it could have gone to tax court so it could relied upon by others. As is, technically, it was only good for that specific client. But, it was very profitable for him, particularly as far as the savings on Social security tax. At this time, I can't remember the name of the book, but there was a very good book for minister's taxes. It use to be in red white and blue cover. (as an aside, even it, did not take tithe as a business expense). I spoke to the author before the audit and he thought I had a good case. Turns out, I did. But, I highly recommend the book. I will see if I can google and find it. The parsonage allowance is one of the most misunderstood concepts of ministerial taxes. Because ministry is such a limited niche, you may have to actually educate your CPA that special allowances exists for ministers.